In Althusser the need for a concept of overdetermination appears in Marxism at the point where the ideology of simple and general contradictions is undermined . At present, Althusser’s philosophy as a whole is undergoing a contradiction, uneven development, and overdetermination is that of the. Richard L. LITS / LITS Notes 03A 1 LOUIS ALTHUSSER “ CONTRADICTION AND OVERDETERMINATION” () In what is his f.
||6 June 2012
|PDF File Size:
|ePub File Size:
||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Unless a circumstance-clause is included, the putative cause to which one overdetermijation to draw attention could never be considered sufficient, and hence not comply with the counterfactual analysis. Cambridge University Press, — In addition, he added to these examples insights from the French tradition of historical epistemology about the way in which sciences come to be constituted.
Among and within these specific practices, there may or may not be tensions. During the s, Althusser lived two lives that were only somewhat inter-related: Though both states and individuals are important elements of the socio-economic whole, nothing philosophical is learned by examining the essence of the individual or the way in which justice is embodied by the contradicrion.
How are these new terms arranged?
Sorry, your browser doesn’t support frames…
Because the past is never more than the internal essence in-itself of the future it encloses this presence of the past is the presence to consciousness of consciousness itself, and no true external determination. Marxist philosophers, he maintained, could be useful to scientists by pointing out, from the standpoint of politics and by the method of historical critique, where and how some of the concepts scientists employed were ideological.
La Formation du myth, —Paris: However, they do so only when the contradictions and levels of development inherent in a mode of production allow for such change. On the other hand, anyone ad wants to attack it, even if the odds are apparently against him, need only discover this one weakness to make all its power precarious. Kukla, Rebecca and Mark Lance, Both texts only appeared posthumously.
Mirror Sites View this site from another server: Begun to treat recurrent bouts of depression, this last affiliation continued for the rest of his life and included frequent hospitalization as well as the most aggressive treatments post-war French psychiatry althysser to offer such as electroconvulsive therapy, narco-analysis, and psychoanalysis.
The logical destination of this temptation is the exact mirror image of the Hegelian dialectic the only difference being that it is no longer a question of deriving the successive moments from the Idea, but from the Economy, by virtue of cnotradiction same internal contradiction. Resch, Robert Paul, However, in another era and in other places, it may be the production and dissemination of religious beliefs and practices that dominates and organizes the socio-economic structure.
Early Work —60 2.
Further, though some order must exist in order to allow for the production and reproduction of social life, there is no essential or best form that this order must take. There, on the 22 nd of October,he died of a heart attack 2. Brandon Carey – – Australasian Journal of Philosophy 89 2: In fact at each moment of its development consciousness lives and experiences its own essence the essence corresponding to the stage it has attained through all the echoes of the essence it has previously been, and through the allusive presence of the corresponding historical forms.
Given his mental state, his frequent institutionalizations, his anomie, and the drugs he was prescribed, these were not very productive years. For example, the German Social-Democrats at the end of the nineteenth century imagined that they would shortly be promoted to socialist triumph by virtue of belonging to the most powerful capitalist State, then undergoing rapid economic growth, just as they were experiencing rapid electoral growth such coincidences do occur.
Althusser, though, is comfortable with this circularity. Though scientists may study and describe these orders in their specificity, it does not at first appear that philosophy can do much except to categorize these interactions at the most general level.
Contradiction and Overdetermination
A much used example is that of firing squadsthe members of which simultaneously firing at and ‘killing’ their targets. The Overdetermination Argument Revisited. At the most, he succeeded in carving out some autonomy for theoretical reflection within the Party. Althusser et la psychanalyseParis: Further, he argued that philosophy still had a role to play in the clarification of scientific concepts. Ideology, or the background ideas that we possess about the way in which the world must function and of how we function within it is, in this account, understood to be always present.
Even in the rapidly written lines of anf afterword to the second edition overdeterminatino Das Kapital Marx saw this difficulty clearly. This body of concepts may be more or less unified and consistent and it may be more or less consciously articulated. That is, there are more causes present than are necessary to cause the effect. This Marxism has no system of interrelated concepts that guarantee a scientific analysis.
But this task is indispensable if we are to be able to express even propositions more precise than these approximations on the character of the overdetermination of Marxist contradiction, based primarily on the existence and nature of the superstructures.
There he enjoyed the comforts of the Mediterranean environment as well as those provided by an extended and stable petit-bourgeois family. First among them, following Democritus, is the thesis that matter is all that exists.
But here we should pay careful attention: The anti-teleological, scientistic, and anti-humanist, Marxist philosophy developed by Althusser over the course of his career works well with the materialist metaphysics recounted above.
There are names for these temptations in the history of Marxism: Inthe fruit of one of these seminars was published as Reading Capital. We must admit that this extraction cannot be painless; in appearance an unpeeling, it is really a demystificationan operation which transforms what it extracts.
Surely, with the overdetermination of any contradiction and of any constitutive element of a society, which means: Before there wasbefore the great historical deceptions of England and Germany, before that the Commune, even earlier the German failure of Moulier Boutang, Yann,